Academic Survey On Practical Test Provision / Delays Underway by WMU Student

A student from Western Michigan University (WMU) is working on his thesis discussing current industry concerns of shortage of practical test provision or challenges in this system. The data from this survey will be completely de-identified from submitters and used for academic purposes, but the data results will also be presented in a paper that will, when completed later this year, be shared with industry members.

If you are a DPE, CFI or flight training provider, or an applicant who has sought or completed practical test events in the last couple of years, please help this student gather feedback and information to make the data robust.

DPEs – Click Here to Complete the Survey

CFIs/Flight Training Providers – Click Here to Complete the Survey

Students/Applicants for Practical Tests – Click Here to Complete the Survey

The Difference Between the Fear of Heights and the Fear of Falling: A Pilot’s Perspective

Fear is a natural human response, and pilots must understand and manage their fears in aviation to perform safely and effectively. Two common fears often confused are acrophobia (fear of heights) and basophobia (fear of falling). While these fears may seem similar, they stem from different psychological and physiological mechanisms. Understanding the distinction between the two can help pilots develop strategies to mitigate their effects and improve their comfort and safety in the cockpit.

For many pilots, the fear of edges, ladders, rooftops, and other places a person may fall is common. Yet, they don’t fear being in a plane at higher altitudes because there is a difference between the fear of falling and the fear of heights.

Understanding the Fear of Heights (Acrophobia)

The fear of heights, or acrophobia, is a persistent and irrational fear of being at an elevated position, regardless of the actual risk of falling. People with acrophobia experience intense anxiety when looking down from a height, even when they are in a secure environment, such as inside a glass-walled observation deck or a commercial aircraft.

Acrophobia is believed to be linked to visual and vestibular processing in the brain. When a person is at a significant height, their brain processes a large amount of visual input regarding their distance from the ground. This information is sometimes misinterpreted, triggering a disproportionate fear response.

When someone with acrophobia is exposed to high places, their body may react with:

  • Increased heart rate
  • Dizziness or vertigo
  • Sweaty palms
  • Shortness of breath
  • Panic or the urge to retreat to a lower altitude

Most pilots do not suffer from true acrophobia because flying in an aircraft provides a sense of enclosure and control. However, some pilots experience mild unease when flying in small aircraft with bubble canopies, such as gliders or helicopters, where the sense of exposure is more significant. Additionally, some pilots may feel discomfort during steep climbs, low-altitude maneuvers, or flights over rugged terrain.

Understanding the Fear of Falling (Basophobia)

The fear of falling, or basophobia, is more instinctive and deeply ingrained in human survival mechanisms. Unlike acrophobia, which is linked to perceived height, basophobia is triggered by a sense of instability or loss of control.

Basophobia is rooted in the human brain’s innate response to balance and stability. To maintain equilibrium, the brain continuously monitors sensory input from the vestibular system (inner ear), proprioceptors (muscle and joint sensors), and visual cues. When these inputs signal a potential loss of balance or support, the brain activates a fear response.

This fear is more situational than acrophobia. For example, standing on solid ground at the edge of a cliff might not trigger basophobia, but suddenly feeling unstable or slipping near that edge would.

When someone experiences the fear of falling, they may exhibit:

  • Sudden panic or muscle tension
  • Reflexive grabbing for support
  • An intense urge to stabilize themselves
  • An urge to move away from the perceived place of falling potential
  • Increased adrenaline levels, often leading to a ‘fight-or-flight’ reaction

For pilots, the fear of falling is more relevant than the fear of heights. Many pilots are not afraid of altitude but may experience discomfort in situations where they perceive a loss of control, such as:

  • Severe turbulence – The unpredictable movements of the aircraft can create a sensation of instability.
  • Stalls and spins – Even experienced pilots can feel an instinctive jolt of fear when the aircraft departs from controlled flight.
  • Rapid descents – Sudden drops, whether due to wind shear, thermals, or intentional maneuvering, can trigger an innate fear response.

Some pilots report feeling this more in open cockpit aircraft, aircraft with see-through doors (such as patrol doors with windows), certainly when flying aircraft without a door on, and frequently for pilots and passengers in balloon baskets where the edge is right next to them.

This type of fear is not irrational—it is an evolved survival mechanism. However, excessive fear of falling can interfere with pilot performance, making training and experience essential to overcoming it.

Most pilots, when flying in stable flight, don’t even feel this type of fear, but may have just such a fear when they are at home trying to clean the leaves in their gutters on a ladder, when looking out over an overlook at a scenic cliff, or other similar such places. It’s just a different fear than heights.

Impact on Pilot Training and Flight Proficiency

Both fears—of heights and of falling—can affect pilot training, but in different ways.

Student pilots who experience discomfort in the air may struggle with certain aspects of training, particularly during:

  • Takeoffs and landings – The proximity to the ground and the rapid changes in altitude can be unsettling.
  • Steep turns – A banked aircraft gives a different visual and physical sensation that may trigger unease.
  • Slow flight and stalls – The unnatural sensation of reduced speed and impending loss of lift can provoke a fear response.

As pilots progress in their training, they encounter maneuvers that can intensify the sensation of falling:

  • Spin recovery – Even though pilots are trained to recognize and recover from spins, the initial sensation can be alarming.
  • Aerobatics – Rolls, loops, and hammerheads introduce new gravitational forces that can disorient the body.
  • Instrument flight—The lack of outside visual reference requires pilots to trust their instruments, which can be difficult for those who strongly rely on visual cues for stability. For some, this triggers a lack of feeling stable during flight.

Strategies for Overcoming These Fears

Pilots can take several steps to overcome their fear of heights or fear of falling, whether mild or severe.

The best way to manage fear is through gradual exposure. Flight instructors can help students build confidence by introducing challenging situations in a controlled manner.

 Using Breathing and Relaxation Techniques

Controlling physiological responses to fear can prevent panic. Pilots can practice breathing and relaxation techniques to help. These might include deep breathing to slow their heart rate, progressive muscle relaxation to reduce tension or focused attention on instruments rather than external stimuli to reinforce the factual information showing an aircraft is stable.

Working with a flight instructor, aviation psychologist, or desensitization therapist can be beneficial for pilots with significant fear. Many pilots have successfully overcome their fears through structured training programs.

While the fear of heights and the fear of falling may seem similar, they originate from different psychological and physiological responses. Acrophobia is linked to the visual perception of height, while basophobia is rooted in the fear of instability or loss of control. The fear of falling is far more relevant for pilots, as it can impact performance.

By understanding these fears and implementing structured training strategies, pilots can overcome anxiety and build confidence. Experience, knowledge, and mental discipline allow pilots to master the skies and their fears, rational or irrational.

Interesting Quirky Certification Data Points 2024

I always find a few just, quirky, curious data points every year when I dig through the data on airman certification. Some of these are just data points that I found interesting or ones that I think might illustrate something curious, at least for me.

I hope you find them equally interesting!

Total of 848,770 airmen certifications held. This is the total number of all airmen certificates that are held in the the national airspace system that the FAA believes are for live people. When you think about that, if we think of this of the total population of the United States (not that every airmen certificate holder is from the United States) at 334,900,000 people roughly according to 2023 numbers, this means that the cool kids (in my opinion as holders of an airmen certificate) represent only 0.253% of people!

Our pilot population is trending younger. When we look at the overall breakdown of our airmen certificate holders ages, the largest percentages of our pilots are not overly senior when it comes to age. As we have continued to create new airmen certificate holders actively in the recent years, we are seeing higher percentages of our pilot population fit the under 40-years old age demographic.

In 2024, we issued 3 recreational pilot certificates. A legacy certificate that is in the regulations yet and possible to be issued, it is rarely used. For those CFI candidates ou there, don’t expect to need to use these regulations very often.

Sport pilot issuances were a little larger number, but still a very small number. 2024 saw 226 initial sport pilot issuances. I bring this one up, because it may be a number than changes in upcoming years. With the potential implementation of MOSAIC (a change that will allow larger aircraft to be flown under sport pilot privelges), there is a potential that this certificate may get more utilization in the upcoming years.

Glider only pilots still remain a limited number of people. Only 175 initial glider certificates were issued in 2024. Most glider pilots still seem to be pilots who also fly other categories/classes of aircraft, and additionally fly gliders.

Most CFI certificates issued in the United States, are issued to U.S. citizens. While the U.S. is a training location for many non-U.S. citizens for pilots seeking private and commercial certificates, instrument ratings, and multi-engine privileges, most of the CFI certificate training is focused on U.S. citizens. This is likely due to the fact that is more challenging for non-U.S. citizens to work in the U.S. as CFIs after they would complete such training, but also because most of those that are here for pilot training transition back to home countries for additional training or service specifically as professional pilots in airline and cargo operations. The CFI certificate is not needed in many of these environments for those pilots to continue to gain experience to meet experience requirements as it is in the United States where additional hours are required for ATP pilot certification flight operations.

Tracking CFIs Certification and the CFIs Population

A continued climb in the number of CFI certificates issued in 2024 was the aberration in pilot certification numbers. With most other certificates and ratings decreasing slightly, the issuance of CFI certificates again climbed slightly to the highest number we have seen in a year since 1990.

The issuance of CFI certificates each year gives us a perspective on how many pilots will be able to gain experience as CFIs in the upcoming years that will be applicable to meeting ATP minimums at a future point in their career.

This is also an indicator of how many flight instructors are being generated each year that can train our next generations of pilots as other CFIs transition out of service in flight instruction positions.

We can also see from the table, and from the chart below, that our average age of CFI certificate holders is decreasing as we heavily populate our incoming CFI certificate holders with younger generation CFIs. Even though our overall CFI certificates held population continues to grow, topping out at 138,127 at the end of 2024, the heavy influx of new CFI populations is going to trend younger, especially as our older generation of CFIs passes away.

We can see from the next chart that the percentage of our CFI population that is over the age of 65, and over the age of 70 continues to grow as a percentage of the overall CFI population. According to CDC data, the average age of men, of which most older CFIs are, is 76 years of age at this point. If we assume this holds, we have to assume that about 20% of our CFIs will reach that average age of death within the next 11 years. This will generate a significant dropoff in the number of CFI certificates held by our older sectors of the pilot population and the heavy influx we have had of younger CFIs in recent years will make the age demographic of our CFI population trend even lower as a percentage of the total.

We have made some changes to our CFI certificate data points at the end of 2024, specifically that CFI certificates will no longer expire going forward. They will just need to be kept “current” and a CFI will have to meet recency requirements to be eligible to use those now non-expiring certificates. Going forward, we will likely have to make some adjustments to this data point and look, if the data is available, at CFI certificates that are within “recency” to compare this data point. It is also unclear at this point how or when the FAA will “remove a CFI from the data calculations, assuming they have passed away. More to come as we dig for more data and look to future years.